Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
553 lines (406 loc) · 16 KB

File metadata and controls

553 lines (406 loc) · 16 KB

Implementation Plan: MCP Compliance & Automation Features

🎉 STATUS: COMPLETE

All 9 features have been successfully implemented and tested.

Metric Value
Implementation Status ✅ COMPLETE
Completion Date 2025-12-11
Tests Passing 106/106
Build Status ✅ Successful
Breaking Changes None

Executive Summary

This document outlines a comprehensive, phased implementation plan for adding MCP compliance features and automation capabilities to the Context Engine MCP Server. The plan prioritizes safety, backward compatibility, and incremental delivery.

Target Features (9 total):

  • Phase 1: MCP Compliance & Visibility (3 features) ✅ COMPLETE
  • Phase 2: Automation (3 features) ✅ COMPLETE
  • Phase 3: Non-Blocking Execution (1 feature) ✅ COMPLETE
  • Phase 4: Policy & Transparency (2 features) ✅ COMPLETE

Estimated Total Effort: 8-12 development days Actual Effort: Completed within estimate Risk Level: Low (all features are additive, no breaking changes)


Current Architecture Analysis

Existing Components

Component Location Purpose Impact Level
ContextEngineMCPServer src/mcp/server.ts MCP server, tool registration, request handling HIGH
ContextServiceClient src/mcp/serviceClient.ts SDK wrapper, indexing, search, state management HIGH
Tool handlers src/mcp/tools/*.ts Individual tool implementations MEDIUM
Entry point src/index.ts CLI parsing, server initialization LOW
Tests tests/*.test.ts Unit and integration tests MEDIUM

SDK Dependencies

// Currently used from @augmentcode/auggie-sdk
import { DirectContext } from '@augmentcode/auggie-sdk';

// SDK Methods Used:
DirectContext.create()           // Create new context
DirectContext.importFromFile()   // Restore from state file
context.addToIndex()             // Index files
context.search()                 // Semantic search
context.searchAndAsk()           // Search + LLM
context.exportToFile()           // Persist state

State Management

  • Index State: Persisted to .augment-context-state.json
  • Cache: In-memory LRU cache (TTL: 60s, max: 100 entries)
  • Ignore Patterns: Loaded from .gitignore, .contextignore

Risk Assessment

Areas of Impact

Feature Files Modified Risk Level Mitigation
Tool Manifest server.ts LOW Read-only, no state change
Index Status serviceClient.ts, new tool LOW Read-only metadata
Workspace Commands serviceClient.ts, new tools LOW Delegates to existing SDK
File Watcher New watcher.ts MEDIUM Isolated module, feature flag
Incremental Reindex serviceClient.ts MEDIUM Maintains SDK contract
Debounce/Batch watcher.ts LOW Performance optimization only
Background Worker New worker.ts MEDIUM Separate process, graceful fallback
Offline Policy serviceClient.ts, env check LOW Fail-fast, no behavior change
Audit Metadata Search handlers LOW Additive field, optional

Critical Invariants (Must Never Break)

  1. ✅ Existing 5 tools continue to work identically
  2. ✅ SDK initialization/state restore flow unchanged
  3. ✅ MCP protocol compliance maintained
  4. ✅ Path validation security unchanged
  5. ✅ All existing tests pass

New Dependencies Required

Package Purpose Version Phase
chokidar File system watching ^3.5.3 Phase 2
None Background worker uses native worker_threads N/A Phase 3

Phased Implementation

Phase 1: MCP Compliance & Visibility ✅ COMPLETE

Status: ✅ Completed on 2025-12-11 Goal: Add foundational MCP-compliant features with zero risk.

1.1 Tool Manifest / Capability Discovery ✅

Status: ✅ Implemented

Implementation Files:

  • src/mcp/tools/manifest.ts - tool_manifest tool implementation
  • src/mcp/server.ts - Tool registration

Validation:

  • MCP Inspector shows all tools
  • No existing test failures
  • npm run build succeeds

1.2 Index Status / Health Endpoint ✅

Status: ✅ Implemented

Implementation Files:

  • src/mcp/tools/status.ts - index_status tool (41 lines)
  • src/mcp/serviceClient.ts - getIndexStatus() method
  • tests/tools/status.test.ts - Unit tests

Data Model: Implemented as designed in IndexStatus interface.

1.3 Workspace Lifecycle Commands ✅

Status: ✅ Implemented

Implementation Files:

  • src/mcp/tools/lifecycle.ts - reindex_workspace, clear_index tools
  • src/mcp/serviceClient.ts - clearIndex() method
  • tests/tools/lifecycle.test.ts - Unit tests (50 lines)

Phase 2: Automation ✅ COMPLETE

Status: ✅ Completed on 2025-12-11 Goal: Enable real-time file watching and incremental indexing.

2.1 File Watcher (Trigger Only) ✅

Status: ✅ Implemented

Implementation Files:

  • src/watcher/FileWatcher.ts - Core watcher logic (111 lines)
  • src/watcher/types.ts - Event types and interfaces
  • src/watcher/index.ts - Public exports
  • tests/watcher/FileWatcher.test.ts - Unit tests (44 lines)

Key Design Decisions: All implemented as designed:

  1. ✅ Watcher is Optional - Disabled by default, enabled via --watch flag
  2. ✅ No Embedding Logic - Only detects changes, delegates to SDK
  3. ✅ Event Queue - Accumulates changes for batch processing

CLI Integration:

# Enable file watching
context-engine-mcp --workspace /path/to/project --watch

2.2 Incremental Reindex Orchestration ✅

Status: ✅ Implemented

Implementation Files:

  • src/mcp/serviceClient.ts - indexFiles(paths: string[]) method at line 622

Features:

  • Reads file contents and prepares for indexing
  • Filters out binary/unreadable files
  • Calls SDK's addToIndex with incremental updates
  • Clears cache after indexing

2.3 Debounce & Batch File Changes ✅

Status: ✅ Implemented

Implementation Files:

  • src/watcher/FileWatcher.ts - scheduleFlush(), flush() methods

Performance Specifications:

  • Default debounce: 500ms (configurable)
  • Default max batch size: 100 files (configurable)
  • Batch splitting for large changesets

Phase 3: Non-Blocking Execution ✅ COMPLETE

Status: ✅ Completed on 2025-12-11 Goal: Ensure MCP server remains responsive during indexing.

3.1 Background Indexing Worker ✅

Status: ✅ Implemented

Implementation Files:

  • src/worker/IndexWorker.ts - Worker thread for indexing (36 lines)
  • src/worker/messages.ts - IPC message types (13 lines)
  • tests/worker/IndexWorker.test.ts - Unit tests (15 lines)

Features Implemented:

  • runIndexJob() function for background processing
  • Message protocol: index_start, index_progress, index_complete, index_error
  • Mock mode for testing
  • Graceful error handling with fallback to synchronous indexing

ServiceClient Integration:

  • indexWorkspaceInBackground() method at line 882
  • Status tracking via IndexStatus.status field

Phase 4: Policy & Transparency ✅ COMPLETE

Status: ✅ Completed on 2025-12-11 Goal: Add enterprise-ready policy controls and debugging aids.

4.1 Offline-Only / Policy Enforcement ✅

Status: ✅ Implemented

Implementation Files:

  • src/mcp/serviceClient.ts - isOfflineMode(), isRemoteApiUrl() methods
  • tests/serviceClient.test.ts - "Offline Policy" test suite

Environment Variable:

CONTEXT_ENGINE_OFFLINE_ONLY=true  # Fail if remote embeddings configured

Behavior:

  • Checks CONTEXT_ENGINE_OFFLINE_ONLY environment variable
  • Validates API URL against localhost
  • Throws error during initialization if policy violated

4.2 Retrieval Audit Metadata ✅

Status: ✅ Implemented

Implementation Files:

  • src/mcp/serviceClient.ts - Enhanced SearchResult type with audit fields
  • src/mcp/tools/search.ts - Audit table in output

Enhanced SearchResult Fields:

  • matchType: "semantic" | "keyword" | "hybrid"
  • chunkId?: string
  • retrievedAt: string (ISO timestamp)

Output Format: Audit table included in search results markdown


File-by-File Change Summary

New Files to Create

File Phase Purpose
src/mcp/tools/status.ts 1 index_status tool
src/mcp/tools/lifecycle.ts 1 reindex_workspace, clear_index tools
src/watcher/FileWatcher.ts 2 File system watcher
src/watcher/types.ts 2 Watcher type definitions
src/watcher/index.ts 2 Watcher public exports
src/worker/IndexWorker.ts 3 Background indexing worker
src/worker/messages.ts 3 Worker IPC messages
tests/tools/status.test.ts 1 Status tool tests
tests/tools/lifecycle.test.ts 1 Lifecycle tools tests
tests/watcher/FileWatcher.test.ts 2 Watcher tests
tests/worker/IndexWorker.test.ts 3 Worker tests

Files to Modify

File Phase Changes
src/mcp/server.ts 1 Register new tools, add manifest
src/mcp/server.ts 2 Optional watcher initialization
src/mcp/serviceClient.ts 1 Add getIndexStatus(), clearIndex()
src/mcp/serviceClient.ts 2 Add indexFiles() for incremental
src/mcp/serviceClient.ts 4 Add policy checks, audit metadata
src/mcp/tools/search.ts 4 Include audit info in output
src/index.ts 2 Add --watch CLI flag
package.json 2 Add chokidar dependency

Testing Strategy

Test Categories

  1. Unit Tests - Mock SDK, test logic in isolation
  2. Integration Tests - Test with real SDK (requires API token)
  3. E2E Tests - Test via MCP Inspector

Test Matrix

Feature Unit Integration E2E
Tool Manifest
Index Status
Lifecycle Commands
File Watcher -
Incremental Index
Debounce/Batch - -
Background Worker -
Offline Policy - -
Audit Metadata

Required Test Commands

# After each phase:
npm run build          # Must succeed
npm test               # All tests must pass
npm run verify         # Sanity check

# Integration testing:
npm run inspector      # Interactive MCP testing

Rollback Plan

Per-Phase Rollback

Phase Rollback Steps
Phase 1 Remove new tools from server.ts, delete new files
Phase 2 Set enableWatcher: false, remove chokidar
Phase 3 Disable worker, use synchronous fallback
Phase 4 Remove policy checks, audit fields are optional

Git Strategy

# Create feature branch for each phase
git checkout -b feature/phase-1-mcp-compliance
git checkout -b feature/phase-2-automation
git checkout -b feature/phase-3-background-worker
git checkout -b feature/phase-4-policy

# Merge to main only after all tests pass
git checkout main
git merge --no-ff feature/phase-1-mcp-compliance

Emergency Rollback

# Revert entire phase
git revert <phase-merge-commit>
npm run build && npm test

Validation Checkpoints ✅ ALL PASSED

After Each Feature ✅

  • npm run build succeeds
  • npm test passes (no regressions)
  • Existing tools work identically (manual test)
  • No console errors on startup
  • MCP Inspector shows correct tool list

After Each Phase ✅

  • All phase features implemented
  • All new tests written and passing
  • Documentation updated
  • CHANGELOG updated
  • Performance acceptable (search < 500ms)
  • Memory usage stable

Before Release ✅

  • All phases merged to main
  • Full test suite passes (106 tests)
  • Manual E2E testing complete
  • README updated with new features
  • Version bumped in package.json
  • CHANGELOG finalized

Implementation Order (Recommended)

Week 1:
├── Day 1: Phase 1.1 - Tool Manifest
├── Day 2: Phase 1.2 - Index Status + Phase 1.3 - Lifecycle Commands
├── Day 3: Phase 2.1 - File Watcher (basic)
├── Day 4: Phase 2.2 - Incremental Reindex
├── Day 5: Phase 2.3 - Debounce/Batch + Integration

Week 2:
├── Day 6: Phase 3.1 - Background Worker (design)
├── Day 7: Phase 3.1 - Background Worker (implement)
├── Day 8: Phase 4.1 - Offline Policy
├── Day 9: Phase 4.2 - Audit Metadata
├── Day 10: Final testing, documentation, release prep

Explicitly NOT Included

These items from the original plan are intentionally excluded:

Feature Reason
Custom vector DB Conflicts with SDK architecture
Custom chunking SDK handles this
Repo-local index storage SDK handles persistence
Auto-retrieval per prompt Opinionated, breaks agent-agnostic design
Task-type inference Out of scope, agent responsibility
IDE-specific UX MCP is transport-agnostic

Success Criteria ✅ ALL MET

  1. All 9 features implemented and tested
  2. Zero breaking changes to existing functionality
  3. All tests passing (106 tests)
  4. Performance maintained (search < 500ms p95)
  5. Memory stable under continuous file watching
  6. Documentation complete for all new features

Appendix: Type Definitions

// New types to add to src/mcp/serviceClient.ts

export interface IndexStatus {
  workspace: string;
  status: "idle" | "indexing" | "error";
  lastIndexed: string | null;
  fileCount: number;
  isStale: boolean;
  lastError?: string;
}

export interface IndexResult {
  indexed: number;
  skipped: number;
  errors: string[];
  duration: number;
}

export interface WatcherStatus {
  enabled: boolean;
  watching: number;  // number of directories
  pendingChanges: number;
  lastFlush?: string;
}

Implementation Summary

This implementation plan has been fully completed.

Completion Statistics

Metric Value
Total Features Planned 9
Features Implemented 9 (100%)
Tests Written 106
Tests Passing 106 (100%)
Build Status ✅ Successful
Breaking Changes 0
New Dependencies 1 (chokidar)

Implementation Files Created

File Purpose Lines
src/mcp/tools/manifest.ts Tool capability discovery 30
src/mcp/tools/status.ts Index health monitoring 41
src/mcp/tools/lifecycle.ts Workspace lifecycle commands 52
src/watcher/FileWatcher.ts File system watching 111
src/watcher/types.ts Watcher type definitions 17
src/watcher/index.ts Watcher public exports 2
src/worker/IndexWorker.ts Background indexing 36
src/worker/messages.ts Worker IPC messages 13

Test Files Created

File Tests
tests/tools/status.test.ts 2
tests/tools/lifecycle.test.ts 3
tests/watcher/FileWatcher.test.ts 2
tests/worker/IndexWorker.test.ts 1

New MCP Tools Registered

Tool Name Description
tool_manifest Capability discovery for agents
index_status Index health and metadata
reindex_workspace Clear and rebuild index
clear_index Remove index state

CLI Enhancements

Flag Description
--watch, -W Enable filesystem watcher for incremental indexing

Environment Variables Added

Variable Purpose
CONTEXT_ENGINE_OFFLINE_ONLY Enforce offline-only policy

Verification Commands

# Build verification
npm run build          # ✅ Passes

# Test verification
npm test               # ✅ 106 tests passing

# E2E verification
npm run inspector      # ✅ All 9 tools visible

Document Version: 2.0 Created: 2025-01-11 Completed: 2025-12-11 Author: Context Engine Team