Skip to content

RFC: Could we set ISO_FILE_SIZE_LIMIT=0 ? #3589

@jsmeix

Description

@jsmeix

This RFC raises the question whether ISO_FILE_SIZE_LIMIT in default.conf can be safely set to 0 (no limit) in ReaR 3.0 after removing ebiso support, or whether a conservative default limit is still required. Since ISO 9660 still documents a 4 GiB single‑extent file size limit, the concern is whether ReaR should keep a non‑zero default such as ISO_FILE_SIZE_LIMIT=4294967296 to avoid creating oversized embedded backup files in the ISO that might be unreadable in practice, especially as there is little real‑world feedback about very large files in ISOs.

See
#3588
starting at
#3588 (comment)

The Wikipedia article
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ISO_9660
still metiones a limit of 4 GiB, see
#2525 (comment)

So perhaps after ebiso support is removed

ISO_FILE_SIZE_LIMIT=4294967296

in default.conf is still needed to be by default on the safe side?

Metadata

Metadata

Type

No type

Projects

No projects

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions