Ana Paula Maia can already count herself a prize-winner having won the Republic of Consciousness Prize in 2024 for Of Cattle and Men, translated by Zoe Perry. While that novel, her first from Charco Press, did not go on to be selected for the International Booker, her follow-up, On Earth As It Is Beneath (translated, on this occasion, by Padma Vishwanathan) has been. It is a brutal novel, though it would be unfair to say it is entirely without hope despite giving that impression throughout most of its pages. The novel is set in a remote prison known as the Colony:
“Little is left, men or animals.”
The man in charge, Melquiades (a name which means ‘righteous king’), has ordered the horses shot, and, as we will discover, has developed a habit of hunting the prisoners so that there are only a few of them left. They dare not escape as a tag has been placed on their ankle which, so they have been told, will explode should they go outside the wall. Death is everywhere in the opening chapter, from the dog (“It died sick, with a sore on its belly that gradually expanded, rotting it”) to the boar that one of the prisoners, Bronco Gil, has killed, the head of which Melquiades wants for his wall. The ground itself is filled with corpses, suggesting that the title has more than religious connotations:
“The worst part is that, whenever we dig a hole in the ground, we find others buried. All that’s left are bones with ropes tied around their wrists and ankles. There are more men underneath than up here, that’s for sure.”
Melquiades’ mental instability is suggested with economy when he quizzes a prisoner, Valdenio, about his own orders, and then repeats his opening question about lunch which has just been answered. All are aware that the camp’s time is almost over as an official is on his way, but the prisoners fear that Melquiades will kill them all before he arrives. For this reason, the remaining prisoners still dream of escape. Bronco Gil even plans to cut off his foot to remove the bomb strapped to his ankle. He has already escaped death having lost an eye to a vulture which ate it after he was run over. Valdenio also believes Melquiades is going to kill everyone: “We’re not going to make it past today.” The guard, Taborda, is aware of Melquiades’ madness but unable to abandon his role:
“He doesn’t agree with any of his superior’s actions and it makes him miserable when the prisoners look at him with fellow feeling. What can he do, he’s not trained to have compassion or disobey. The feeling of hierarchy eats away at him like a worm.”
Despite the barren landscape and the empty prison, the novel has a claustrophobic feel with each of the characters trapped, both prisoners and guards. We learn a little of Bronco Gil’s back story, how he first killed a man for money, but nothing of Melquiades, who begins hunting the men the same day he has the horses shot, further narrowing the possibility of escape. The novel’s final scenes play out cinematically as the official, unlike Godot (of whom we might have been reminded), does appear, but it is perhaps a little too cinematic when the ironic justice served on Melquiades is replaced by a gun battle.
The novel deals with a legacy beyond the prison and Melquiades’ madness. The bones date long before the prison as the Colony “was always shrouded in some mystery involving mass disappearance and murder…
“More than a hundred years ago, when the enslaved people living here were mostly tortured and killed, it was known as the Black Calvary.”
This is highlighted by a box the prisoners uncover, the contents of which are not revealed until the end. It is also significant that Bronco Gil, the most sympathetic character, is an ‘Indian’, ‘bronco’ suggesting that he cannot be tamed. He provides the novel with what little hope there is, being “good at staying alive and keeping predators at bay.” On Earth As It Is Beneath is the kind of novel which leaves its images in the mind long after it is read, whether we might want them there or not. Whether the judges have the stomach to progress it to the International Booker shortlist remains to be seen.























