Skip to content

Clean up Comment vs UserComments vs CommentAction #170

@vickitardif

Description

@vickitardif

http://schema.org/Comment
http://schema.org/CommentAction
http://schema.org/UserComments

Schema.org currently has three overlapping types:

Comment: A subtype of CreativeWork described as "A comment on an item". Oddly enough, it does not allow for including the body of the comment. One can only describe the comment (e.g. author, date published, etc.)

CommentAction: "The act of generating a comment about a subject." It also does not include the body of the comment.

UserComments: A subtype of UserInteraction. It is the "event" of commenting. The only way to include the comment body.

The only place where Comment and UserComments are used as an expected type is on the "comment" property of CreativeWork.

This is all very confusing and should be cleaned up.

Status (May 1) for sdo-gozer

TODOs before closing this issue

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

schema.org vocabGeneral top level tag for issues on the vocabulary

Type

No type

Projects

No projects

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions