• 1 Post
  • 728 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: October 15th, 2023

help-circle










  • I agree with you that their plight has been exploited, certainly by the U.S., without really getting real, long term benefit for themselves.

    No state wants to legitimize them because there will be an immediate influx and then they’ll just legislate their independence (or fight for it), once they got big/established enough.

    When I saw that we were arming the Kurds again to potentially fight Iran, I was wondering if we are not just creating another Al Qaeda scenario for ourselves. That and, I wondered if they would just start fighting Turkey instead

    How many stateless groups are there outside of the Kurds and the Armenians?

    I don’t even know how to begin to resolve what the modern Middle East looks like. I would love to prevent the large groups from just destroying the small groups, but then I feel like haven’t we fucked it up enough already, with our meddling?







  • sartalon@lemmy.worldto Memes of Production@quokk.aucolony
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    41
    ·
    14 days ago

    Served in the Navy and was stationed in Japan for three years.

    It is not inaccurate.

    TLDR: The U.S. is not taking over Japanese assets and under any circumstances barring alien invasion and kaiju. (In the case of kaiju, we should probably operate under Japanese control.)

    While we practice/train with the JMSDF, and have ok interoperability, there is zero infrastructure for us to control them.

    It would actually hurt us and would be easier to tell them to stay home while we did everything than to try and control both assets at the same time.

    However, we can work together, by assigning each service their own responsibilities and let each perform those responsibilities within their own chain of command. That would work peachy.

    In that sense, we may have overall strategic command, but the Japanese would absolutely have a seat at the strategic table, and the Japanese would and should take their toys and go home, the minute we asked them to do something against their best interest.